nov 072013


On the edge of the nearby galaxy Messier 86, astronomers have observed a strange X-ray flash. This flash has almost certainly been caused by a rare cosmic accident in which a small star is pulled apart by a medium-sized black hole. The discovery may provide the missing evidence for the existence of medium-sized black holes.

Simulation of signal

Two phases from a simulation of a white dwarf being ripped apart by an intermediate black hole. The colors in this figure indicate the amount of gas of the ripped-apart star, where yellow indicates the highest density and black the lowest. We see two stills from a simulation for a similar system as that under study. To the right are the remains of the star and a stream of material falling to the black hole. The black hole is here indicated with a white circle at a position of 0,0. There are enhancements in the amount of material visible in the stream of material to the black hole. These enhancements at regular intervals of time, cause an increase in the amount of X-ray light coming from the vicinity of the black hole. The X and Y axis indicate the distance to the black hole in units of hundred thousand kilometers. For reference, the distance between the Moon and the Earth is approximately four hundred thousand kilometers. Image Credit: Stephan Rosswog et al.

The X-ray signal which was investigated by Dutch astronomer Peter Jonker and his team (SRON, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen), first of all reveals two small emissions with a pause of 4,000 seconds in between. Another 4,000 seconds later the quantity of x-ray radiation suddenly increases by a factor of 100 and then gradually decreases again. This is very similar to the signal predicted for a medium-sized member of the family of black holes, which pulls apart a so-called white dwarf (the remnants of a Sun-like star).

The period of 4,000 seconds concurs with the time needed for the material from the torn star to rotate once around a black hole about 10,000 times as heavy as the Sun. These medium-sized black holes – astronomers have also discovered small and supermassive black holes – could have arisen early in the history of the Universe from the first generation of super stars. The space around galaxies should therefore be full of these but up until now there was no strong evidence for the presence of this intermediate type of black hole.

Tip of the iceberg

The discovery by Peter Jonker et al. may provide the missing evidence. Jonker: “This is probably the tip of the iceberg because we have found more of this strange type of X-ray flashes. Aidan Glennie, PhD student at Oxford, is working with me on a study of two comparable signals from different galaxies. As the chances of such a black hole capturing a star and pulling it apart is very small, this means that there are probably many medium-sized black holes.”

Messier 86 is a giant elliptical or lenticular galaxy that is one of the brightest members of the Virgo Cluster of Galaxies. Image Credit: Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope/Coelum

If more medium-sized black holes were found, it would make it more plausible that supermassive black holes evolved from the merging of medium-sized black holes. The presence of supermassive black holes in the early universe in particular, is difficult to explain if there are no medium-sized black holes.

Hopefully it will also be possible to observe the merging process in the near future with the improved LIGO, Virgo and eLISA facilities. Astronomers hope to use these to measure the gravity waves transmitted by two merging medium-sized black holes. It might also be possible for the astronomers to compare the characteristics of the strongly deformed space-time surface near a black hole with Einstein’s predictions. This is because a white dwarf is torn apart very close to a black hole.

Research and publication

Peter Jonker’s research took place at SRON Netherlands Institute for Space Research in Utrecht and at Radboud University Nijmegen. Jonker could observe the X-ray flash thanks to observations from NASA’s space telescope Chandra. For their discovery, he and his team ploughed through hundreds of thousands of X-ray sources discovered by chance, searching for abnormal patterns.

The research results have been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal, under the title “Discovery of a new kind of explosive X-ray transient near M86“. The publication can be found online at:

Source: SRON (The Netherlands Institute for Space Research)

Share this post